Skip to main content

Rustic Tavern

Rustic Tavern & Sports Bar logo top - HomepageRustic Tavern & Sports Bar logo scroll - Homepage

Sports Bar

  • (973)-234-5836
  • rustictexmex@gmail.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gallery
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Rustic Tavern & Sports Bar logo top - HomepageRustic Tavern & Sports Bar logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gallery

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Seafood Fridays
  • Seafood Madness
  • Taco Tuesday
  • Steak Night Special
  • Dessert Menu

Starters

Gourmet Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
$13.00
Jalapeño Cheddar Cheese Poppers (8)
$11.00
Potato Skins
$11.00
Fried Pickles
$8.00
Chicken Fingers

4 fingers & French fries $10.00 | 8 fingers & French fries $17.00

Mozzarella Sticks

6 sticks $9.00 | 12 sticks $13.00

Stadium Pretzel
$11.00

With cheese dip or mustard

Disco/ Chili Fries
$10.00
Truffle Parmesan French Fries
$9.00
Butterfly Shrimp Basket
$13.00

Served with French fries

Wing Central

Breaded-Naked-Boneless

6 wings $10.00 | 12 wings $19.00 • Served with celery and choice of ranch or blue cheese | Buffalo, Hot Honey, Garlic Parm, Jamaican Jerk, Mango Habanero, BBQ

Salads

Add to any salad: Chicken +$4.00 | Steak +$5.00 | Shrimp +$5.00
Choice of ranch, Blue Cheese, Balsamic

Garden Salad
$12.00

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion

Caesar Salad
$12.00

Romaine lettuce with shreds of parmesan and ciabatta wedges

Steaks

Served with chef choice vegetable, and choice of baked, rice, french fries, or green beans

Ribeye Steak
$40.00

16 oz-marinated in our chef’s secret soy-based sauce

T-Bone
$40.00

16 oz- juicy filet and flavorful strip, basted with garlic butter sauce

Filet Mignon
$40.00

8oz- center-cut filet, natural char and tenderness

Tavern Sliders

Served with French fries • Sub Onion Rings +$2.00 | Sweet Potato Fries +$2.00 | Salad +$2.00 | Truffle Parm French Fries +$3.00

4 Cheeseburger
$15.00

Topped with carmelized onions

4 Pulled Pork
$15.00

Topped with cheddar cheese & caramelized onions

4 Chicken Parm
$15.00

Topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese

Specialty Gourment Burgers

Served with French fries • Sub Onion Rings +$2.00 | Sweet Potato Fries +$2.00 | Salad +$2.00 | Truffle Parm French Fries +$3.00 | Double Burger Patty +$8.00

Classic
$16.00

8 oz with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion • Add Bacon +$4.00 | Add Mushroom +$3.00

Brisket Burger
$16.00

Served with cheddar cheese, bbq sauce, raw white onion, horseradish pickles

Blackened Burger
$16.00

Topped with caramelized onions & crumbled blue cheese

Swiss Mushroom Burger
$16.00

Melted Swiss cheese, sauteed mushrooms in a demi glaze

Turkey Burger
$14.00

Topped with provolone cheese, avocado, and scoop of pico

Veggie Burger
$14.00

Layered with house made guacamole, lettuce, and tomato

Pasta Dishes

Lobster Mac & Cheese
$22.00
Cajun Chicken Alfredo
$22.00
Baked Ravioli with Marinara
$22.00
Penne Alla Vodka
$22.00

Choice of grilled chicken, grilled shrimp

Chicken Parmesan Platter
$22.00

Breaded cutlet with marinara, mozzarella, and pasta

Eggplant Parmesan Platter
$22.00

Breaded cutlet with marinara, mozzarella, and pasta

Handhelds

Served with French fries • Sub Onion Rings +$2.00 | Sweet Potato Fries +$2.00 | Salad +$2.00 | Truffle Parm French Fries +$3.00

Ribeye Cheesesteak Sub
$18.00

8oz ribeye steak with cheese, peppers, onions, mushrooms

Cuban Sandwich
$16.00

Slow-roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, mustard

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$15.00

Buffalo chicken in tortilla with lettuce, cheddar, ranch or blue cheese

Chicken Caesar Wrap
$15.00
Chicken Sub
$15.00

Grilled or breaded, lettuce, tomato, mayo, ranch or chipotle mayo

Eggplant Parmesan Sub
$15.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub
$15.00

Tex Mex Starters

Queso and Chips
$10.00
Guacamole and Chips
$10.00
Nachos
$12.00

Add Chicken +$4.00 | Seasoned Beef +$4.00 | Pulled Pork +$4.00

Bangin’ Shrimp with Avocado
$16.00
Steak Tostones
$16.00

4 crispy tostones, topped with guacamole, slices of tender steak topped with balsamic chimichurri glaze

Cauliflower Florets
$12.00

Tossed in a smoky chili-lime seasoning, crowned with crumbled cotijia cheese and drizzle of crema fresca

Empanadas

4 Large in house made filled with choice of • Chicken or Beef. $16.00 | Corn & Bean $15.00

Quesadillas
$13.00

Tortilla with melted monterrey jack and cheddar, peppers, onions, served with salsa, sour cream • Add Chicken +$4.00 | Steak +$5.00 | Shrimp +$5.00 | Pork +$4.00

Rustic Street Corn
$12.00

Sweet fire grilled corn off the cob, tossed in a chili-lime mayo, topped with crumbed queso and cotija cheese

Salads & Bowls

Southwest Grilled Fajita Salad
$12.00

Add Chicken +$4.00 | Steak +$5.00 | Shrimp +$5.00

Tex Mex Bowl
$14.00

Romaine, rice, corn, pico, black beans and cheese in a large tortilla shell • Add Seasoned Beef +$4.00 | Chicken +$5.00 | Shrimp +$5.00

Blackened Salmon Salad
$19.00

8oz salmon, field greens, crowned with tangy mango salsa and slices of avocado. choice of ranch, blue cheese, and balsamic

Ranchero Veggie Salad
$14.00

Charred seasonal veggie, served over cilantro rice, crowned with creamy avocado-mango salsa, crumbled cotija cheese, and a drizzle of zesty lime crema

Tacos

Taco Trio

Choice of Beef, Chicken, or Spiced Shrimp in hard or soft shell $17.00 | Corn & Bean $15.00

Pork Carnitas
$17.00

Slow roasted pork with cilantro, diced onions, verde sauce

Baja Fishtacos
$19.00

Blackened mahi-mahi with guacamole and mango salsa

Tex Mex Entrees

Enchiladas Blancas

3 corn tortillas filled with monterrey jack cheese and topped with cotija cheese and queso cheese sauce • choice of Beef or Chicken $18.00 | Corn & Bean $16.00

Rustic Burrito
$18.00

Giant tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken or seasoned beef, rice, black beans, melted cheese, smothered with red enchilada sauce

Chimichanga
$18.00

Tortilla stuffed with beef or chicken, melted cheese, deep fried, finished with queso

Cantina Combo
$20.00

Includes mini burrito (beef, or chicken), cheese enchilada (beef or chicken) topped with red enchilada sauce, and a crispy beef taco

Fajitas

Veggie $16.00 | Steak $20.00 | Chicken $19.00 | Shrimp $20.00 | Combo of 2 $22.00 • Served with peppers, onions, warm tortillas, side of guac, and sour cream

Seafood Selections

Tequila-Lime Shrimp
$22.00

Sauteed shrimp tossed in zesty tequila, lemon herb sauce, nestled atop a mango-cucumber salsa with sliced avocado

Grilled Salmon
$25.00

8 oz cajun-spiced filet topped with mango-cucumber salsa

Salmon Bowl
$26.00

8 oz pan seared salmon filet over lettuce, tomato, rice, cucumber, cauliflower, broccoli topped with a teriyaki glaze

Kids Menu

Served with kids drink

Hot Dog and Fries
$6.00
Mac and Cheese
$6.00
Chicken Fingers and Fries
$8.00
Kids Cheese Quesadilla
$7.00

Chicken $8.00

Kids Taco and Fries
$7.00

Beef or Chicken

Kid’s Cheese Pizza
$7.00
Baked Ravioli with Marinara
$9.00

Sides

Rice and Beans
$4.50
Green Beans
$4.00
French Fries
$5.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.00
Onion Rings
$5.00
Small Guacamole
$3.50
Side Salad
$5.00
Side of Sour Cream
$2.00

During lent

Menu

Clams
$15.00/2 doz

Steamed with: Butter | Garlic Wine | Fra Diavolo

Mussels
$15.00/2 doz

Flavors: Tequila Lime | Coconut Curry | Fra Diavolo | Garlic Wine

Seafood Cakes
$18.00

Filled with scallops, crab & shrimp served with Thai chili sauce

Panko Fried Butterfly Shrimp
$12.99

With fries

Yellowfin Tuna
$15.00

Sesame-crusted or blackened with rice or greens

Fish n' Chips
$18.00

3 pieces of beer-battered fries

Twin Lobster Tails
$36.00

Served with drawn butter, veggies & potato

Salmon Dijonaise
$24.99

Grilled with chef veggie & choice of potato

Mid week | Wednesday & Thursday

Menu

Sesame Crusted Yellowfin Tuna
$15.00

Served over mixed greens or rice with a choice of dressing

Clams

1 doz $9.00 | 2 doz $15.00 • Options: Steamed with Butter | Garlic Wine Sauce | Fra Diavolo Sauce

Mussels

1 doz $9.00 | 2 doz $15.00 • Options: Tequila Lime Broth | Coconut Curry Broth | Fra Diavolo Sauce

Seafood Cakes

Filled with scallops, crab, and shrimp, served with sweet chili sauce

Food

$2.00 tacos all day

Taco
$2.00/each
Chicken
$2.00/each
Beef
$2.00/each
Pork
$2.00/each
Shrimp
$2.00/each
Beans
$2.00/each

Drinks

From 12 pm - 6 pm

House Margarita
$5.00

Regular | Strawberry | Mango raspberry

Corona
$4.00

Every Saturday | All Gourmet Steaks for $29.99

Menu

Served with a choice of French fries, rice, mashed potatoes, baked potato, or green beans

Rib Eye

A juicy, hand-cut rib eye steak, marinated in our chef's secret soy-based sauce, then flame-grilled to perfection | Tender, savory, and packed with flavor

New York Strip

Bold and robust, a coffee-rubbed strip steak, char-grilled and sliced, then finished with a silky coffee liqueur reduction | A rich twist on a classic cut

Cowboy Steak Diane

A hearty cowboy steak, pan-seared and flambéed in cognac | Served in a luxurious mustard and black pepper cream sauce indulgence on a plate

T - Bone

The best of both worlds, juicy filet and flavorful strip, grilled and basted with garlic butter sauce | Big, bold, and built for steak lovers

Tuscan - Style Porterhouse

A porterhouse marinated in olive oil, balsamic vinegar, fresh garlic, and rosemary. Rustic, aromatic, and bursting with Italian countryside flavors

Filet Mignon Steak

Our classic center-cut filet, grilled over an open flame for natural char and unmatched tenderness

Surf & Turf
MP

8 oz filet mignon cooked to perfection, with a tender lobster tail and melted butter

Menu

Lil Red Velvet Cake
$7.99

Rich red velvet cake is layered with sweet cream cheese filling and finished with a dark chocolate feather garnish.

Mango Guava Cheesecake
$7.99

A refreshing duo of brightly flavored mango & guava cheesecakes rest on a classic graham crust. We've topped this tropical dessert with a light mango mousse and finished it with toasted almonds.

Carrot Cake
$7.99

Carrots, pecans, pineapple and sweetened coconut are combined to create two delicious layers of moist carrot cake which alternate with layers of smooth cream cheese filling accented with natural vanilla. Topped with freshly baked carrot cake crumbs.

Cheesecake
$7.99

NY Style Cheesecake

Dulce De Leche Cake
$7.99

Naturally flavored vanilla cake with a light and airy dulce de leche mousse and a silky glaze topped with caramel chocolate-covered cereal.

Chocolate Lava Cake
$7.99

A rich, moist hand crafted chocolate ganache is surrounded by a delectable chocolate cake.

Flourless Chocolate Cake
$8.99

A mixture of chocolate and pasteurized egg products is slowly baked to a soft chewy consistency. Finished with an apricot glaze on top and sprinkled with confectionary sugar.

Tres Leche Cake
$7.99

Dairy-soaked sponge cake layered with creamy vanilla whipped cream.

Churro Cake
$9.99

Filled with Tres Leches, chocolate syrup and whipped cream.

Churros
$7.99

Served with or without cinnamon.

Brownie Sundae
$10.99

Choice of 2 scoops of ice cream w/chocolate syrup.

Ice Cream
$6.99

2 scoops-vanilla, chocolate, trash can, cookies n cream.

  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs